Report an error   


Submitted: 26 January 2012 Modified: 16 August 2016
HERDIN Record #: PCHRD12012609205650

A comparative study using lidocaine, thiopental and metoclopramide as pre-treatment in reducing propofol pain on injection.

1Joanna V. Florendo,
2Theresa Barrios,
3Nelia Laborte,
4Jocelyn Reyes
Department of Anesthesiology - St. Luke's Medical Center

Abstract

OBJECTIVS: Propofol-induced pain injection occurs in 30-90 percent of patients. Various strategies have been advocate to minimize this nuisance with variable results. Lidocaine pretreatment is the most popular method for reducing this pain but this drug cannot entirely eliminate the problem. the purpose of this study was to compare the analgesic effect of lidocaine with thiopental and metoclopramide accompanied by venous occlusion.


METHODS: In a randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled trial, 144 ASA I-II patients, scheduled for elective surgery under general anesthesia were randomly assigned to 1 of 4 groups. Group I received 2 ml of plain NSS, group II received lidocaine 40 mg, group III received thiopental 0.5mg/kg and group IV received metoclopramide 10 mg. All pretreatment drugs were made into 2 ml solutions and were given IV with manual venous occlusion of 1 minute. Propofol was administered after release of venous occlusion. pain was then assessed using a four-point scale and face pain scale during propofol injection.


RESULTS: 36 patients (100%) complained of pain in the control group compared with 20 (56%), 22 (61%) and 23 (64%) in the lidocaine, thiopental and metoclopramide groups, respectively (p<0.05). there was no significant difference among the 3 test solution with regards to severity of pain. Nor were there any noted complications 24 hours postoperatively on the injection site.


CONCLUSION: Thiopental and metoclopramide are equally effective as lidocaine in reducing pain during propofol injection when used with manual venous occlusion.

1.
Publication Type:
Journal
Publication Sub Type:
Journal Article, Original
Title:
Philippine Journal of Anesthesiology
Frequency:
Annual
Publication Date:
July-December 2008
Volume:
20
Issue:
2
Page(s):
25-31
Publisher:
The Philippine Society of Anesthesiologists, Inc.

LocationCall NumberAvailable FormatAvailability
Philippine Council for Health Research and Development Library Box No. 115 Fulltext pdf (Request Document)
1. Macario, A , Weinger, M , Troung , P , Lee, M . "Which clinical anesthesia outcomes are both common and important to avoid? The perspective of a panel of expert anesthesiologists" Anesth Analg 88, 1085-1089, 1999 - [External Link]
2. Nathanson, M H, Gajraj, N m, Russell, J A. "Prevention of pain on injection of propofol: a comparison of lidocaine with alfentanil" Anesth and Analg 82, 467-471, 1996 - [External Link]
3. Fujii, Y , Nakayama, M . "Reduction of Propofol-Induced Pain through Pretreatment with Lidocaine and/or Flurbiprofen" Clin Drug Invest 24(12): 749-753, 2004 - [External Link]
4. King, Sy , Davis, F M, Wells, J E, Murchison, D J, Pryor, P J. "Lidocaine for the prevention of pain due to injection of propofol" Anesth Analg 74, 246-249, 1992 - [External Link]
5. O Hara, JR Jr, Sprung, J , Laseter , JT , et al., . "Effects of topical nitroglycerin and intravenous lidocaine on propofol-induced pain on injection" Anesth Analg 84, 865-869, 1997 - [External Link]
6. Agarwal, A , Ansari, M F, Gupta, D , et al., . "Pretreatment with thiopental for prevention of pain associated with propofol injection" Anesth Analg 98, 683-686, 2004 - [External Link]
7. Picard, P , Tramer, M . "Prevention of pain on injection with propofol: a quantitative systematic review" Anesth Analg. 2000 Apr;90(4):963-9. 90, 963-969, 2000 - [External Link]
8. Aurswald, K , Pfeiffer, F , Behrends, K , Burkhardt, U , Olthoff, D . "Pain on injection with propofol" Anesthesiol Intesivmed Notfallmed Achmersther 40(5): 259-266, 2005
9. McCrirrick, A , Hunter, S . "Pain on injection of propofol: the effect of injectate temperature" Anaesthesia 45, 443-444, 1990 - [External Link]
10. Ishiyama, T , Kashimoto, S , Oguchi, T , Fukushima, H , Kumazawa, T , Furuya, A . "Clonidine-ephedrine combination reduces pain on injection of propofol and blunts hemodynamic stress responses during the induction sequence" J Clin Anesth 18(3): 211-215, 2006 - [External Link]
11. McCluskey, A , Currer, B A, Sayeed, I . "The efficacy of 5% lidocaine-prilocaine (EMLA) cream on pain during intravenous injection of propofol" Anesth Analg 97, 713-714, 2003 - [External Link]
12. Cheong, M , Kim, K , Choi, W . "Ephedrine reduces the pain from propofol injection" Anesth Analg 95, 1293-1296, 2002 - [External Link]
13. Agarwal, A , Raza, M , Dhiraaj, S , Pandey, R , Gupta, D , Pandey, C K, Singh, P K, Singh, U . "Pain during injection of propofol: the effect of prior administration of butorphanol" Anesth Analg 99, 117-119, 2004 - [External Link]
14. Ambesh, SP , Dubey , PK , Sinha, PK . "Ondansetron pretreatment to alleviate pain on propofol injection: a randomized, controlled, double-blinded study" Anesth Analg 89, 197-199, 1999 - [External Link]
15. Memis, D , Turan, A , Karamanlio?lu, B , Sut, N , Pamukcu, Z . "The use of magnesium sulfate to prevent pain on injection of propofol" Anesth Analg 95, 606-608, 2002 - [External Link]
16. Fujii, Y , Nakayama, M . "A lidocaine/metoclopramide combination decreases pain on injection of propofol" Can J Anaesth 52(5): 474-477, 2005 - [External Link]
17. Bieri, D , Reeve, RA , Champion, GD . "The Faces Pain Scale for the self-assessment of the severity of pain experienced by children: development, initial validation, and preliminary investigation for ratio scale properties" Pain 41, 139-150, 1990 - [External Link]
18. Sun, NC , Wong, AY , Irwin, MG . "A comparison of pain on intravenous injection between two preparations of propofol" Anesth Analg 101, 675-678, 2005 - [External Link]
19. Yull, DN , Barkshire, KF , Dexter, T . "Pretreatment with ketorolac and venous occlusion to reduce pain on injection of propofol" Anaesthesia 55, 284-287, 2000 - [External Link]
20. Scott, RPF , Saunders, DA , Norman, J . "Propofol: clinical strategies for preventing the pain of injection" Anaesthesia 62, 202-203, 1999 - [External Link]
21. Ohmizo, H , Obara, S , Iwama, H . "Mechanism of injection pain with long and long-medium chain triglyceride emulsive propofol" Can J Anaesth 52, 595-599, 2005 - [External Link]
22. Pang, WW , Mok, MS , Huang, S , Hwang, MH . "The analgesic effect of fentanyl, morphine, meperidine, and lidocaine in the peripheral veins: a comparative study" Anesth Analg 86, 382-386, 1998 - [External Link]
23. Overbaugh, R , Jones, P , Nguyen, A , Swaney, G . "Effect of mixed versus unmixed lidocaine with propofol" The Int J of Anesthesiology 7(2): 2003 - [External Link]
24. Tan, LH , Hwang, NC . "The effect of mixing lidocaine with propofol on the dose of propofol required for induction of anesthesia" Anesth Analg 97, 461-464, 2003 - [External Link]
25. Lai, YY , Chang, CL , Yeh, FC . "The site of action of lidocaine in intravenous regional anesthesia" Acta Anesthesiol Sin 31, 31-34, 1993 - [External Link]
26. Eriksson, M , Englesson, S , et al., . "Effect of lignocaine and pH on propofol-induced pain" Anesth Analg 78, 502-506, 1997 - [External Link]
27. Morgan, GE , Mikhail, M , Murray, M . Nonvolatile anesthetic agents. Clinical Anesthesiology The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., 2002. 159. (3rd ed.) - [External Link]
28. Klement, W , Arndt, JO . "Pain on injection of propofol: effects of concentration and diluent" Br J Anaesth 67, 281-284, 1991 - [External Link]
29. Anker-Moller, E , Spangsberg, N , Arendt-Nielsen, L , et al., . "Subhypnotic doses of thiopentone and propofol cause analgesia to experimentally induced acute pain" Br J Anaesth 66, 185-188, 1999 - [External Link]
30. Lee, TW , Loewenthal, AE , Strachan, JA , Todd, BD . "Pain during injection of propofol. The effect of prior administration of thiopentone" Anaesthesia 49, 817-818, 1994 - [External Link]
31. Ganta, R , Fee, JP . "Pain on injection of propofol: comparison of lignocaine with metoclopramide" Br J Anaesth 69, 316-317, 1992 - [External Link]
32. Rosenblatt, LP , White, M . "The effects of premedication on anesthesia with propofol (Diprivan)" Postgrad Med J 6, 35-37, 1985
33. Fujii, Y , Uemura, A . "Effect of metoclopramide on pain on injection of propofol" Anaesth Intensive Care 32(5): 653-656, 2004 - [External Link]