Report an error   

Submitted: 16 May 2007 Modified: 13 April 2018
HERDIN Record #: PCHRDPC040617

Comparative study between 1-propanol, 2-propanol & mecetronium ethyl sulfate (sterillium) hand-rub and chlorhexidine gluconate (microshield) hand-scrub for surgical hand disinfection.

1Martin Ranellus P. Samson,
2Martin Anthony A. Villa,
3Jeffrey J. Domino,
4Deogracias Alberto G. Reyes,
5Edgardo R. Cortez
Department of Surgery - St. Luke's Medical Center


Two popular hand disinfectant solutions based on different principles and mechanisms of action were compared as to their ability to eradicate aerobic bacteria and their duration of action. Forty participants were chosen randomly forming two groups. Group A employed the hand scrub method using chlorhexidine (Microshield) and Group B the hand rub method using 1-propanol, 2-propanol and mecetronium ethyl sulfate (Sterillium). Culture swabs were taken from a 25 sq cm area over the palm before, immediately after and two hours after disinfection. The results showed an average of 50,000 colony forming units (CFUs) of bacterial species among the participants before hand disinfection. No bacterial growth was noted immediately after hand disinfection. However, two hours later there were 8 out of 20 (40 percent) positive growth for Group A (30,000 to 70,000 CFUs) and 4 out of 20 (20 percent) positive growth for Group B (40,000 to 70,000 CFUs). T-test statistical analysis revealed no significant difference between the two groups. (Author)

Publication Type:
Publication Sub Type:
Journal Article, Original
Philippine Journal of Surgical Specialties
Publication Date:
April-June 2001
Philippine College of Surgeons

LocationCall NumberAvailable FormatAvailability
Philippine Council for Health Research and Development Library Box No. 6 Fulltext pdf (Request Document)
1. White, J J, Wallace, C K, Burnett, L S. "Drug letter, skin disinfection." Hopkins Med J 126, 169, 1970
2. Lowburry, EJ L, Lilly, H A, Bull, J P. "Methods of disinfection of hands and operation sites" Br Med J 2, 531-536, 1964 - [External Link]
3. Kaul, A F, Figgis, J . "Agents and techniques for disinfection of the skin " Surg Gynecol Obstet 152, 677-685, 1981
4. Ayliffe, G A. "Surgical scrub and skin disinfection " Infection Control 5(1): 23-27, 1984
5. Ayliffe, G A, Babb, J R, Davies, J G, et al, . "Hand disinfection: A comparison of various agents in laboratory and ward studies" J Hosp Infect 1(3): 226-243, 1988 - [External Link]
6. Dineen, P . "An evaluation of the duration of the surgical scrub" Surg Gynecol Obstet J , 1181-1184, 1969
7. Widmer , A F, Perschmann, M , Gasser, T C, et al, . Alcohol vs. chlorhexidine digluconate for preoperative hand scrub:. A randomized cross over clinical trial. Poster Session, 34th Interscience Conference on Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy. Orlando Florida, USA: 1994. (Oct 4-7)
8. Osmunden, P E. "Contact dermatitis of chlorhexidine" Contact Dermatitis 8(2): 81-83, 1982 - [External Link]
9. Rotter, M , Koller, W , Kundi, M . "Usability of three alcohols for a standard disinfection method " Zentralbl Bakteriol 164(5-6): 428-438, 1977 - [External Link]
10. Kalmar, P , Steinhagen, R H. "Surgical hand disinfection using alcoholic rubbing disinfectants" Chirurg 55(4): 280-287, 1984 - [External Link]